Between Age Gap & Heartfelt Drama: Book Review 12 Years by Chetan Bhagat
When a popular author like Chetan Bhagat returns to the romance genre, expectations gravitate upward. His latest novel, 12 Years: My Messed-Up Love Story, released in October 2025, is already making waves. It’s earning praise for its entertainment value and criticized for its more controversial elements. In this Book Review, I explore how the novel is being received, what works well, and what might make some readers pause. Overall, Goodreads shows ~4.6/5, Amazon.in ~4.5/5, indicating strong reader approval.
Book Details at a Glance
- Title: 12 Years: My Messed-Up Love Story
- Author: Chetan Bhagat
- Publisher: HarperCollins India
- Release Date: October 2025
- Genre: Contemporary Romance / Popular Fiction
- Main Characters:
- • Saket Khurana — a 33-year-old divorced stand-up comic • Payal Jain — a 21-year-old rising star in private equity, conservative family background, no prior relationship experience
Content Highlights & Praise
Here are the aspects reviewers are appreciating:
- Relatable, Entertaining Storytelling
The novel feels like a Bollywood romance with highs and lows. Many readers find it easy to read, engaging, and fun. It has humour, emotional moments, and the kinds of dramatic twists people expect. - Contemporary Themes
It touches on issues young urban Indians care about — societal expectations, mental health, family background, age differences, choosing unconventional paths. It mirrors modern relationship scenarios including situationships. - Simple, Conversational Prose
Bhagat’s strength has always been writing for mass readers. His style is direct, with light humour and straightforward storytelling. That helps make the work accessible to many. - Dramatic Premise That Invites Discussion
- The large age gap (33 vs 21), divorce, background clash (Punjabi vs Jain, experienced vs inexperienced) gives tension. Some social media criticism arises from this, calling it “problematic.” But many readers say it’s that tension which gives the story its spark.
Common Critiques: What Doesn’t Fully Work
While many like the book, these points appear repeatedly in feedback:
Concerns Over Age Gap
Many social media voices find the 12-year age gap between Saket (33) and Payal (21) problematic. Some label it “creepy” or question ethical implications in power dynamics. Bhagat responds it is part of the story’s conflict.
Predictability & Stereotypical Characters
Some argue that the plot feels recycled — love-meets-obstacles, family pressures, misunderstandings. Characters occasionally fall into familiar molds.
Simplistic Emotional Depth
At times, emotional moments are spelled out rather than shown. The dilemmas of the characters could have been more subtly drawn.
Highlights: Book Review of 12 Years by Chetan Bhagat
- If you like stories that make you reflect about love and social rules, this will provoke thought.
- If you enjoy romance, family conflict, and a mix of humour + emotional depth, this novel will satisfy those vibes.
- Even with its flaws, it has top ratings (Goodreads ~4.6/5, Amazon.in ~4.5/5) showing most readers are on board.
Chetan Bhagat’s 12 Years: My Messed-Up Love Story, published in October 2025 by HarperCollins India, is already stirring conversations. The novel with its Bollywood-style romance and strong emotional beats has won high scores — Goodreads (~4.6/5), Amazon.in (~4.5/5) — but it hasn’t avoided criticism. The plot centers on Saket, 33 and divorced, and Payal, 21 with no romantic history. They come from differing backgrounds, yet their connection refuses to be simple. Many praise the story as an entertaining, fast read; others find its age gap premise and stereotyped characters problematic. For those who love romance, conflict, societal tension, and real-life dilemmas, this Book Review confirms 12 Years is worth your shelf, even if it doesn’t shy away from messiness.
What’s Happening at Kerala Literature Festival 2026: A Living Carnival of Ideas by the Sea
Every January, Kozhikode turns into a living library….
Kerala Literature Festival Returns to Kozhikode in January 2026
Every January, literature in India finds a rhythm…
Jaipur Literature Festival 2026: Where Stories Shape the World
Every January, Jaipur transforms into a living library….
12 Years: My Messed-Up Love Story — A Book Review of Chetan Bhagat’s Bold Return to Romance
From this Book Review, I conclude that 12 Years: My Messed-Up Love Story is not perfect, but it delivers exactly what many readers want: a fast, emotionally charged, modern romantic drama. It doesn’t aim to be literary high art, and for many of its strengths, it shows its limits. But for fans of Bhagat, of Bollywood narratives, or simply for someone seeking a readable, dramatic romance, it achieves those goals—and more.
Discover more from Read Mitra
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
